Cthulhu Death May Die Fear the Unknown Token Organizer

This puts all of the punchboard tokens in one place, and will fit in the top of the box with no additional lid lift. I've also included one for the original game which fits in the token tray.

Bonus: A ring that fits player-sized enemies and holds up to three tokens. Useful for damage or Azathoth Cosmic tokens. Or use the configurator to make one exactly for what you need.